The script was based on a 1949 short story by dorothy m. Feb 24, 2018 the man who shot liberty valance was released in 1962 and celebrity culture obsession, i would argue, was still relatively premature. The man who shot liberty valance synopsis fandango. The man who shot liberty valance 77 movie clip showdown with liberty valance 1962 hd. Political heroism as depicted in the man who shot liberty valance introduction john ford directed the movie, the man who killed liberty valance. The man who shot liberty valance 1962 directed by john. It is unsatisfactory to call the film plain optimistic, which it was in the middle of the movie, as the beginning but more so the end was pessimistic. Jan 11, 2016 the man who shot liberty valance is a 1962 american western film directed by john ford starring james stewart and john wayne. He had married hallie and had a successful career in politics. The man who shot liberty valance 1962 was another nostalgic and memorable bw john forddirected film about the passing of the old west and the rise of civilization it was his last great film. The man who shot liberty valance 1962 movie summary on mhm. Its adapted from a 1953 short story written by dorothy m.
As a lawyer he came to shinbone to bring law and order to the west by means of law books. Featuring a trio of classic leading men and a rich story captured by a director at the peak of his craft, the man who shot liberty valance is. Questions arise when senator stoddard james stewart attends the funeral of a local man named tom doniphon john wayne in a small western town. The man who shot liberty valance, the new yorkers richard brody writes, is the greatest american political movie. The two betterknown stories, liberty valance and a man called horse only run about 30 pages each. But yet it differs considerably from the story adapted by hollywood writers and made into a movie starring jimmy stewart, john wayne, lee marvin and vera miles. The idealistic young lawyer rance is waylaid by the psychotic outlaw liberty valance. Although most sources say the man who shot liberty valance was shot almost entirely at paramount studios, with exteriors on the janss conejo ranch in thousand oaks, california, a documentary about the making of it revealed that the town and train shots were done on lot 3 at mgm. In the story the title already has the curious doublemeaning that is the key to the plot and to our paradox. To a journalist, who s wondering what the senator is doing in shinbone, he tells how his career started as the man who shot liberty valance. The man who shot liberty valance story structure database. Analysis of the man who shot liberty valance 1647 words 7 pages. The woman who shot liberty valance firefly and western.
Johnson, and starring john wayne and james stewart, ford chose to shoot the film in blackand. Flashing back, we learn doniphon saved stoddard, then a lawyer, when he was roughed up by a crew of outlaws terrorizing the. The long screenplay from a short story by dorothy m. The latter is important for shinbone, because in short time a census will be hold to. Multiple stories and speculations exist to explain this decision. But in addition to drawing on americana, ford created it. All three joined forces only once for the man who shot liberty valance 1962, one of the last films in fords prolific career and one of his most accessible and enduring efforts. Luckily, the man who shot liberty valance more than survives this handful of less impressive moments. Ransom stoddard is for better and worse, the man who shot liberty valance, even if he was pacifist by nature and did not want to shoot liberty valance and ultimately did not shoot liberty valance, that reputation got him into political office and led him to do great deal of good for the lawless town and promote much progress. In the man who shot liberty valance, senator ransom stoddard returns home to the town of shinbone for the funeral of tom doniphon. Johnson, and it principally examines the evolution from rugged frontier individuality to enlighten law and order. A short ensuing flashbackwithinaflashback was introduced with a swirl of smoke from doniphons cigarette and a filmic dissolve. This two hour long, nostalgic modernday western was one of the masters last westerns, and it had a.
The mystery of the misquoted quote from the man who shot. Mar 11, 2018 when famed director john ford decided to make the man who shot liberty valance 1962, a western adapted from a short story written by dorothy m. The appearance of john wayne and james stewart in the man who shot liberty valance accentuates the diverse concepts in play in this western directed by john ford. The poster that launched liberty valance originally published in slightly different form in sight and sound, autumn 1978, volume 47 no. Jan 05, 2017 the man who shot liberty valance 77 movie clip showdown with liberty valance 1962 hd. Yet, while it is an enjoyable film it falls distinctly shy of its innate story potential. Of all john ford westerns, several of them truly great, only one of them produced a signature line. The western is intrinsically the most political movie genre, because, like platos republic, it is concerned with the founding of cities, and because it depicts.
The man who shot liberty valance 1962 rotten tomatoes. Man who shot liberty valance examines precisely this paradoxical situation and, i argue. This line is remembered superficially, and most viewers dont perceive the raw emotions and brutal reality that the statement. The man who shot liberty valance 1962 is the last truly important movie in the career of director john ford as liberty valance begins, the period we see in the film is roughly the same time that ford first began making westerns, in the second decade of the 20th century.
In the man who shot liberty valance, the newspaper editor says, this is the west. The theme was about how a significant falsehood and legend had helped to. In the present day we see the now senator ransom stoddard attending his late friend doniphons funeral. When the stagecoach is held up by outlaws, he is savagely beaten by liberty valance. Director john ford worked with western icon john wayne whom he made a star with 1939s stagecoach on more than twenty films, and jimmy stewart on just three. But i was surprised on watching the film again, that it was mere an emotionally engaging film. So either tom shot at exactly the same moment as liberty ortom shot at the same time as ransom and took advantage of ransoms insecurities by claiming to have shot liberty. End flashback, the editor of the shinbone star takes his notes and burns them, adressing stoddard and summing up his political career, rooted in the fact that hes the man who shot liberty valance. An exclusive analysis of john fords nexttolast western by kevin costner. It has definite themesa controlling idea if you recognize the phrasewhich i had not noticed before. Dec 29, 20 the man who shot liberty valance has long been one of my favorite films, but i had not seen it in a very long time, partly because it is such a dark film in many ways.
Johnson, feeling that dorothy marie sounded too frilly. The man who shot liberty valance illinois state bar association. To a journalist, whos wondering what the senator is doing in shinbone, he tells how his career started as the man who shot liberty valance. Just dont take a drink every time john wayne says pilgrim, or you wont make. Characters in the film the man who shot liberty valance. While she was a student at whitefish high school she. The exact same footage is used for both the man who shot liberty valence and tales of wells fargo years 4 and. The man who shot liberty valance tom doniphon, the outlaw hero, shot liberty valance to protect hallie and ransom stoddard because he knew that ransom is the right future for his town and hallie, even though ransom views contradict with toms views and wishes. The man who shot liberty valance was based on a short story by dorothy m. But i was surprised on watching the film again, that it was mere an emotionally engaging.
The man who shot liberty valance analysis discuss dramatica. Dorothy marie johnson yearned to break into the boys club of western story writers. A senator returns to a western town for the funeral of an old friend and tells the story of his origins. An analysis of the man who shot liberty valance, directed by john ford, starring. Jan 03, 2010 so read the opening of dorothy johnsons short story, the man who shot liberty valance. Nov 16, 2010 the man who shot liberty valance, he shot liberty valance he was the bravest of them all. Standing up for liberty valance true west magazine. Political heroism as depicted in the man who shot liberty. In most stories, this would be the climax, not the third plot point.
The man who shot liberty valance western, large print. The man who shot liberty valance steak scene youtube. John fords the man who shot liberty valance, remembered for when the legend becomes fact, print the legend. The man who shot liberty valance 1962 synopsis sen. Welsh coal miners, the story resembles a dream, seen in retrospect by a man. Granted it was nothing like today which is why the response to the press is unique in the film. This book is a collection of four short ish stories the man who shot liberty valance, a man called horse, lost sister and the hanging tree. Liberty valence is the toughest man south of the picket wire. The man who shot liberty valance movie quotes rotten.
The blackandwhite film was released by paramount pictures. So either tom shot at exactly the same moment as liberty ortom shot at the same time as ransom and took advantage of ransoms insecurities by. Jerome, i suspect several of the dramatica consultants will differ with you on your quickturnaround evaluation of the man who shot liberty valance since the flashback bulk of the movie is framed by the vignettes of ransom and hallie on the train to and from washington, dc, you have to be careful about deciding whether the train scenes are actual story or merely a frame. The reporter has no intentions of publishing the story now and declares the saying that, what you do not know will not hurt you. But in this story, the death of the antagonist isnt actually the point. In a retrospective analysis, the new york times called liberty valance. Johnson, published in her 1953 collection indian country. They were ranked as four of the top five stories of the 20th century by the western writers of america, with the man who shot liberty valance as number one.
The screenplay by james warner bellah and willis goldbeck was adapted from a 1953 short story written by dorothy m. Johnson, and starring john wayne and james stewart, ford chose to shoot the film in blackandwhite, and he did so on a paramount stageset. A lawyer goes west and ends up in a small town thats being terrorized by a gunfight. Johnson has stewart as a dude eastern attorney forging idealistically into lawless western territory, where he. When he meets a local newspaper reporter, he recounts his version of the events surrounding the shooting of liberty valance. The man who shot liberty valance has long been one of my favorite films, but i had not seen it in a very long time, partly because it is such a dark film in many ways. It is the question that launches the entire conflictand which is mirrored back to rance throughout. Edith head received an oscar nomination for best costume design. The man who shot liberty valance was released in 1962 and celebrity culture obsession, i would argue, was still relatively premature. Doniphon informed him about the real truth of the legendary gunfight ransom had not shot liberty. The man who shot liberty valance 1962 plot summary imdb.
Just finished watching the man who shot liberty valance and was struck by how clearly the argument is made for justice by force vs justice by law. The man who shot liberty valance news the harvard crimson. Jun 15, 2018 the man who shot liberty valance, a short story by dorothy m. An analysis of the film the man who shot liberty valance. Throughout the movie, social nad political immoralities unfold. The man who shot liberty valance, a short story by dorothy m. People joke about how reporters will do anything for a story. He had come to town many years before, a lawyer by profession. The man who shot liberty valance is an entertaining and emotionally involving western. Fords movie was derived from an eponymous short story by dorothy.
That story plus a man called horse and the hanging tree became major hollywood films. The man who shot liberty valance, he shot liberty valance he was the bravest of them all. A song from the movie the man who shot liberty valance the man who shot liberty valance is a 1962 american western film directed by john ford starring james stewart and john wayne. The man who shot liberty valance english literature essay. So read the opening of dorothy johnsons short story, the man who shot liberty valance. The man who shot liberty valance turner classic movies.
In the man who shot liberty valance, the newspaper editor says, this is the. When senator ransom stoddard returns home to shinbone for the funeral of tom doniphon, he recounts to a local newspaper editor the story behind it all. An analysis of the film the man who shot liberty valance by. The man who shot liberty valance has been so widely discussed, dissected and applauded that by now it must rank as one of john fords least underappreciated films. Rance then confesses to a reporter that he was not the one that had killed liberty valance rather it had been doniphon who had been hiding and shot liberty to save ransoms face. The supporting cast features vera miles, lee marvin, edmond obrien, andy devine. For anyone interested, heres my quick analysis, done mostly as an exercise to help better understand the dramatica theory. Its reputation is due in no small part to the obvious. When the fact becomes legend, print the legend, fords films show the legend. There, doniphon and stoddard share a closer relationship, doniphon proactively mentoring the younger and less experienced man. The senators political career has been built on his killing of the villainous liberty valance.
The man who shot liberty valance is both optimistic and pessimistic. This is a fabulous and fairly short scene from a classic revisionist western. May 21, 2009 originally published in slightly different form in sight and sound, autumn 1978, volume 47 no. The man who shot liberty valance 1962 was another nostalgic and memorable.
The film has played a great role in dissemination of the american west. The man who shot liberty valance is a 1962 american western film directed by john ford, starring john wayne and james stewart. The man who shot liberty valance analysis culturedallroundman. First, have students read the short story by dorothy m. Ransom stoddard and his wife hallie, visitors from washington, d. We flashback to ranses arrival in the town as a freshfaced attorney as he tells the true story surrounding valances death. Dorothy marie johnson december 19, 1905 november 11, 1984 was an american author best known for her western fiction.
However, neither schickel, nor john ford, nor the screenwriters, nor larry mcmurtry refer to the original source that gave rise to those oftquoted words a short story published in 1953 by dorothy m. Senator, travels by train to the tiny western town of shinbone for the funeral of tom doniphon, a man whom the press has never heard of. When famed director john ford decided to make the man who shot liberty valance 1962, a western adapted from a short story written by dorothy m. The middle of the film was optimistic because it showed the joyous pers. The man who shot liberty valance is a 1962 american western film directed by john ford. Just as the story depicts a dying old west, the feature film was really the last of the great westerns, with director john ford overseeing an at times savage deconstruction of the genre that had done so much for himself, wayne, and to a lesser extent, stewart. Dorothy marie johnson was born in mcgregor, iowa, the only daughter of lester eugene johnson and mary louisa barlow. The man who shot liberty valance critics consensus. Her story the man who shot liberty valance was turned into a. Liberty valance concerns the end of the old west, as the society of a small. And then, to everyones shock, rance pulls off a lucky shot and kills valance.
38 1040 431 3 878 291 956 682 243 1212 403 331 407 851 626 687 817 367 465 1250 635 1265 1626 853 1274 1548 1502 1158 901 1547 194 512 904 372 1219 442 245 800 988 310 577 305